Jury Discussions Begin in 2022 Murder Trial of Schenectady’s VibeZ Bar

February 27, 2024

Updated: February 27, 2024

SCHENECTADY — The jury has begun deliberations in the trial of Markeith Buchanan, who stands⁣ accused of a fatal ⁤shooting outside VibeZ Bar & Lounge in‍ Schenectady in⁤ 2022.

At 25 years old, Buchanan is facing a ‌felony charge of second-degree murder, along⁢ with two ⁤charges of criminal possession of a ‍weapon. If found ‍guilty, he could be sentenced to anywhere between 15⁤ years to life and 25 years to ⁤life in‌ prison for the murder charge.

Judge Matthew Sypniewski clarified‌ to the jury on Tuesday that if they do not find Buchanan guilty of the murder charge, they can still‌ consider convicting him on ⁣the lesser charges of first-or- ‍second-degree⁢ manslaughter.

During his closing statement,‌ Buchanan’s attorney, Kurt ⁤Haas, repeatedly showed video footage of his client being assaulted on the night of ⁤the ‍July 1, 2022 incident. Haas argued that Buchanan did not intentionally kill John Bass that ‍night.

“My client retrieved his gun from his car for⁢ self-defense,” Haas stated. “He had no intention to shoot or kill John Bass. This is evident from his own testimony and his actions that night.”

Haas further argued that if Buchanan had intended to kill ⁢Bass, he would have had multiple opportunities ⁣to do so before Bass was within 3-to-6‌ feet of him⁢ when he was shot. ⁢Haas maintained that Buchanan⁤ shot Bass once because he felt it was necessary.

“I ‌propose to you‍ that ⁣my client’s actions were justified,” Haas said. “My client did what he believed was⁤ necessary.”

Throughout the four-day trial, video footage captured from cell‌ phones, ⁤the⁤ bar’s surveillance ⁢system, and the Schenectady Camera Project was presented to the jury to illustrate the events of ‍that night. The footage shows Buchanan being assaulted by Bass and being labeled a “snitch.” The defense argues that this confrontation led Buchanan to fear for his⁢ life and retrieve his gun from his⁢ car for protection. The prosecution, however, ‌contends that Buchanan retrieved his gun ‌not for‍ protection, but for retaliation.

Intent and justification cannot coexist, Schenectady County Assistant District ⁣Attorney Nicholaus McDonald told the jury.

“Buchanan himself stated that it was not a kill-or-be-killed situation,” McDonald said.

The prosecutor argued that after Bass had exposed Buchanan as a “snitch” ‍and assaulted ‌him, Buchanan had ⁤ample opportunities to leave the⁢ scene.

“The defendant was the initial ‍aggressor, and he was the only one to introduce deadly physical ‍force,” ⁤McDonald said.

McDonald argued that the initial altercation should⁢ have been the⁣ end of the story, but Buchanan went to his car, retrieved his gun, ‌and then shot Bass when he was within 3-to-6 feet of him in the parking lot.